Theory-driven statistical modeling for semantics and pragmatics: A case study on grammatically generated implicature readings

Autor(en): Franke, Michael 
Bergen, Leon
Stichwörter: Bayesian model selection; computational modeling; grammaticalism; Language & Linguistics; Linguistics; pragmatics; PROBABILISTIC PRAGMATICS; SCALAR IMPLICATURE
Erscheinungsdatum: 2020
Herausgeber: LINGUISTIC SOC AMER
Journal: LANGUAGE
Volumen: 96
Ausgabe: 2
Startseite: E77-E96
Zusammenfassung: 
Computational probabilistic modeling is increasingly popular in linguistics, but its relationship with linguistic theory is ambivalent. We argue here for the potential benefit of theory-driven statistical modeling, based on a case study situated at the semantics-pragmatics interface. Using data from a novel experiment, we employ Bayesian model comparison to evaluate the predictive adequacy of four models that differ in the extent to and manner in which grammatically generated candidate readings are taken into account in four probabilistic pragmatic models of utterance and interpretation choice. The data provide strong evidence for the idea that the full range of potential readings made available by recently popular grammatical approaches to scalar-implicature computation might be needed, and that classical Gricean reasoning may help manage the manifold ambiguity introduced by grammatical approaches to these. The case study thereby shows a way of bridging linguistic theory and empirical data with the help of probabilistic pragmatic modeling as a linking function.
ISSN: 00978507
DOI: 10.1353/lan.2020.0034

Show full item record

Page view(s)

2
Last Week
0
Last month
0
checked on Feb 22, 2024

Google ScholarTM

Check

Altmetric